Ask The Rabbi... August 20, 1994 Issue #31 ======================================================================== This issue is dedicated in the memory of Roslyn Seltzer-Leventhal ======================================================================== This edition contains: 1. Putting animals "to sleep." 2. Assorted Shabbat questions. ======================================================================== Richard from Mt. Vernon, NY, wrote: >As a "follow-up" to your answer about Euthanasia, is it Halachically >permitted to put animals "to sleep"? * * * * * * * * Dear Richard, The prohibition against causing pain to animals is a serious one, and is treated as such by Jewish Law, which not only forbids man from causing pain to animals, but also bids him to help relieve the pain of animals. I spoke to Dr. Kaufman, a Jerusalem veterinarian, to find out what putting animals to sleep involves, and under what circumstances the procedure is done. She told me that, in general, she would do this only for animals that had been in an accident and the ensuing treatment would be too costly, or for pets dying and in pain. Though, when Dr. Kaufman was working at the Tufts University Animal Clinic, a woman wanted her dog "put down" for an unusual reason: She had just redecorated her house, and her "lovey, lovey, koochie koo" no longer matched the decor! Even though Dr. Kaufman suggested giving the dog up for adoption, the lady refused, stating that if she couldn't have her "lovey, lovey" then no one could!" The general method for putting an animal to sleep is to give it Phenobarbital, an anesthetic. Once the animal is unconscious, it is given an overdose. The method for putting many animals to sleep at one time is to gas them with Carbon Dioxide, an anesthetic that eventually stops their breathing. In short, every effort is made to make the process painless. I asked Rabbi Chaim Pinchas Scheinberg, shlita, about the ruling in this case, and he told me that it would be Halachically permissible to put an animal to sleep since it is a painless procedure. However, there is a Kabbalistic tradition, he notes, that forbids the ending of any life. Rabbi Aryeh Levin tells a story about a walk he once took with Rabbi Kook. While they were walking, Reb Aryeh "absent-mindedly" pulled a leaf from a tree. Rabbi Kook stopped and asked him why he did that. "Why I did what?" responded Reb Aryeh. Reb Aryeh relates that Rav Kook illustrated to him how one should be very careful about life, even the life of a leaf. Sources: Shemot, 23:5. Talmud - Tractate Shabbat 128b. Shulchan Aruch - Choshen Mishpat, 272:9. ======================================================================== Michael Steinberg from Syracuse wrote: >Are magnets "muktza" on Shabbos? * * * * * * * * Dear Michael, Normal magnets are not muktza on Shabbat. Of course, they may used only for activities permitted on Shabbat. Source: "The Halachos of Muktza" - Rabbi P. Bodner, Lakewood, page 23. ============================= Ira Rosen from Rutgers asked: >May one use a tap on Shabbat that has a water filter attached to it, given >that it separates certain items from the water? The filter is permanently >attached. Does it make a difference if the filter must be turned on? >Thank you for your time. * * * * * * * * Dear Ira, It is permitted to use on Shabbat the filters you have described as long as the water is potable even without the use of the filter -- and the filter is there "just to be extra safe." I assume that is the case where you live. In terms of "turning it on," as long as you did not need to throw an electrical switch, it would be permitted to "redirect" the water to the filter from the spigot. Source: Rabbi Yehoshua Neuwirth - Shemirath Shabbath 3:56. ============================= Elias in the Old City of Jerusalem wrote: >Dear Rabbi, > >I run a Shabbos playgroup for children. Occasionally, one of them will >cause a disruption, and I want to eject the child from the group. Is this >"borer" (the prohibition against "forbidden selecting")? * * * * * * * * Dear Elias, "Borer" is only an issue if there is a mixture of two or more components. If the children are not heaped up in a pile or the like, the prohibition of borer does not apply. If they are in a pile, then either scatter them first, or pull the offender out from the pile for immediate "use." BTW, was this question serious? Source: Rabbi Yehoshua Neuwirth - Shemirath Shabbath 3:1-3. ========================================================================= -> Get Ready for the Ohr Somayach Winter JLE <- 3 weeks of study and touring (Departure December 22) Minimum scholarship price: $599 Covers round trip ticket, room, board, tuition and tours Contact Rabbi Zalman Corlin for details ========================================================================= Ohr Somayach is proud to announce: The Jerusalem Echoes Audio Library Catalog - On Line!! Accessing this catalog couldn't be easier. If you access from Internet, issue the command: gopher jerusalem1.datasrv.co.il at your prompt, or just find "Jerusalem1" listed on the gopher you already have access to. America-On-Line users can access the j1 gopher through the GOPHER/WAIS area within AOL. Once you are in, look for "Religious Institutions" and then "Ohr Somayach." This service is available _exclusively_ on Jerusalem1. We are sorry to say that this means that users without access to Gopher (such as those on Compuserve & Prodigy) will not be able to access this service. ========================================================================= Ohr Somayach Institutions is proud to present a new list: "Yachad" (Together) A monthly list designed for Alumni of Ohr Somayach Jerusalem. Each month, you'll be able to: o Read brief articles written by your former Rabbis. o Read brief esssays submitted by Alumni. o Find out what's happening at Ohr Somayach world-wide. o Share your "Special Occasions" and post personal notices. To subscribe, send the message: sub os-alum {firstname} {lastname} to: listproc@jer1.co.il ========================================================================= Dedication opportunities are available for Ask the Rabbi. Please contact us for details. ========================================================================= Jewish L EEEEEEEE Prepared by Ohr Somayach Institutions J L E 22 Shimon Hatzadik Street, POB 18103 J L Exchange Jerusalem 91180, Israel J J L E Tel: 02-810315 Fax: 02-812890 JJJJ Learning EEEEEEEE Internet: ohr@jer1.co.il ========================================================================= (C) 1994 Ohr Somayach International - All rights reserved. This publication may be distributed to another person intact without prior permission. We also encourage you to include this material in other publications, such as synagogue newsletters. However, we ask that you contact us beforehand for permission.